Every September, the new iPhone is hard to get hold of. At eBay, the opportunity was in the old ones.
Early adopters had older phones to sell. Retailers who wanted an allocation of the new model had to stop selling previous-generation ones, which left them with inventory to clear. Yet nearly-new, certified refurbished iPhones were still in short supply. Demand was there. The challenge was unlocking trusted inventory.
Synthesis, connecting the signals. Our marketplace data showed when previous-generation phones came onto the market and at what price. A longstanding relationship with a key seller showed us the supply dynamics behind those patterns: where inventory came from, what constrained it and how the market worked. Combining the two revealed where we could act.
Decision discipline, making the economics work. Spotting the opportunity was the easy part. The harder question was where to commit. We needed to understand seller margins, supply constraints and what would make bringing more stock to eBay worthwhile. I focused on reputable sellers who could meet the certified refurbished standard: a warranty, returns and free shipping, on terms that worked for buyers, sellers and eBay. Stock that could not meet those service requirements did not get certified. Deciding what not to certify mattered as much as deciding what to bring in.
Connected ecosystems, trust enabling execution. eBay does not sell its own stock, so sellers saw us as a partner. That trust let us work together to unlock additional supply. Data showed us the gap. Partnerships with sellers showed us how to close it.
So what changes with AI? It can now connect signals across far more sources, including unstructured information that used to take significant effort to analyse. But an opportunity only becomes a business when it is commercially viable, and that takes judgement, an understanding of incentives, and trust. As analysis gets cheaper, commercial judgement and execution become more valuable. That is the shift from seeing to acting.
Where does your plan stall between seeing and acting?