Loyalty infrastructure is getting cheaper. Choosing the right partner just got harder

There is genuine opportunity for smaller brands to win in customer loyalty now. Brands that know who to connect with, and why.

For years, sophisticated loyalty partnerships have mostly favoured businesses with enormous customer bases, mature data capabilities and the budgets to build bespoke integrations. For smaller brands, participating in someone else’s ecosystem has often meant joining a queue rather than shaping the proposition. That is starting to change.

Benji, a New York loyalty infrastructure provider, raised $6.25m to build an API layer that connects loyalty programmes to each other, turning what used to be a seven or eight figure, year-long integration into something that can happen much faster. Once that plumbing is commoditised, the competitive question stops being whether you can build this, and becomes who you connect with and what customer pain point you are solving together.

This matters because loyalty itself has become increasingly hard to differentiate. Points and discounts are still important, but years of training customers to expect them have left a lot of programmes looking remarkably similar. The more interesting opportunity is relevance: a travel brand and a hospitality brand, or a fitness platform and a nutrition brand, each holding a different part of what a customer is really trying to do. Done well, that is the difference between a programme that rewards behaviour that would have happened anyway, and one that influences it.

But easier infrastructure just moves the difficult questions upstream. Which brands genuinely share customers and moments, rather than just a demographic? What value can they create together that neither can create alone? What data should, and should not, move between them, and who owns the customer relationship when it works? Bink is the cautionary tale: backed by both Barclays and Lloyds, it still could not get enough retailers and customers moving together before going into administration in 2024. Easier plumbing does not solve a genuinely two-sided problem on its own.

My hypothesis: as the technology gets easier, partner selection and proposition design become the real competitive advantage.

Previous
Previous

The best customer experiences make us feel known. So do the best working relationships

Next
Next

Ask your teams, separately, what customer problem your 2027 strategy exists to solve